5 min read January 27, 2021
Skip to content

Do Service Dogs Make a Difference?

⚕ This content is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional legal, medical, or clinical advice.
Quick Answer
Yes, service dogs and emotional support animals make a significant difference for people with disabilities and mental health conditions. Research demonstrates they help alleviate symptoms of PTSD, anxiety, depression, and social isolation. A 2016 study found emotional support animals provide security and routine while facilitating social connections. A 2018 systematic review confirmed their positive impact on treating mental health problems, with evidence showing overwhelming benefits for individuals with emotional and mental disabilities.

With much negative press about peacocks, hamsters, and pigs on planes, do emotional support animals even make a difference?

The general public, businesses, and lawmakers are confusing, especially since terms like "service animal", "emotional support animal" and "therapy animal" are often interchangeably misused. Public perception validates that most people believe that service dogs and emotional support dogs are being properly used, despite mainstream media's negative coverage of headlines.

What’ s the difference between service animals, emotional support animals, and therapy animals?

Understanding the differences of these terms helps to clear some of the muddy waters. Emotional support animals are not merely pets, but animals that provide a therapeutic support to their owners with a mental or emotional disability.

Service animals are defined by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)  as dogs trained to perform tasks for individuals wit

h disabilities. Whereas, emotional support animals are defined by the Fair Housing Act, which categorizes service animals and emotional support animals in the same category. Of course, these two laws do cause confusion.

To add to the confusion, Air Carrier Access Act categorizes these two terms together, which is what mostly makes headlines about exotic animals flying on a plane or a dog biting a person during a flight.

In effort to prevent abuses, many airlines have strengthened their policies to require specific forms to be completed by licensed practitioners and veterinarians.

Do these animals even make a difference for those who "need them"?

Emotional Support Animal on Dock

Much research has indicated that animals help to alleviate certain symptoms related to psychological issues, including PTSD and anxiety.  Emotional support animals and therapy animals help alleviate stressanxietydepression, and feelings of loneliness and social isolation. Interactions with emotional support animals help people manage their long-term mental health conditions.

2016 study explored the role of animals in the social networks of people managing a long-term mental health problem and found that e

motional support animals provide a sense of security and routine that provided emotional and social support.

Studies have also shown that emotional support animals are facilitators of getting to know people, friendship formation and social support networks.

Another 2018 study reports emotional support animals provide powerful companionship for people living with mental health problems, which used a systematic review and narrative synthesis of the evidence to find statistical significance. Emotional support animals have a positive impact on treating people.

The evidence is overwhelming on the positive impact an emotional support animal has on the treatment of individuals with emotional and mental disabilities.

How to obtain proper documentation for an ESA

Obtaining the proper documentation, like an emotional support animal letter and airline forms, is critical to assure protection by federal and local laws. Following these guidelines for accurate and confidential information:

  1. Completed by a licensed mental health professional,

  2. Establishes a doctor/patient relationship under care of the practitioner,

  3. Utilizes the appropriate language indicating a diagnosable disability by the current edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Health Disorders (DSM),

  4. Validates and verifies a license of the practitioner who signs the documentation.

How to know a website is not a fake, a scam, or a fraud

With so many online websites offering generic emotional support animal registration and documents, the following information is critical:

  1. Verify the website is a healthcare provider, and not a marketing agency. Usually the company is a nonprofit and looking to help support individuals and not make money.

  2. Verify the website is HIPPA compliant and protects your personal information. Nearly all websites collect your information and use it for marketing purposes.

  3. Check the reviews of the website by searching the "company's name" and "reviews" on your web browser. For example, type in "org Reviews" in the search bar.

  4. Check the website will provide the most current airline forms without charging extra fees for completing additional forms.

If you think an emotional support animal or service animal will benefit you, then register with TheraPetic!


GetStarted

Frequently Asked Questions

What' s the legal difference between service animals and emotional support animals?
Service animals are defined by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) as dogs trained to perform specific tasks for individuals with disabilities. Emotional support animals are defined by the Fair Housing Act and provide therapeutic support to owners with mental or emotional disabilities, but aren' t task-trained like service animals.
What research supports the effectiveness of emotional support animals?
Multiple studies demonstrate their benefits. A 2016 study found they provide security and routine while facilitating social connections. A 2018 systematic review showed statistical significance in their positive impact on treating mental health problems, particularly helping with PTSD, anxiety, depression, and social isolation.
Who can provide proper documentation for an emotional support animal?
Documentation must be completed by a licensed mental health professional who has established a doctor-patient relationship with you. The letter must use appropriate language indicating a diagnosable disability according to the current DSM and include verification of the practitioner' s license.
How can I avoid fraudulent ESA websites?
Verify the website is a healthcare provider (not a marketing agency), ensure it' s HIPAA compliant, check online reviews by searching the company name plus ' reviews,' and confirm they provide current airline forms without extra fees. Legitimate providers are typically nonprofits focused on helping individuals rather than profit.
Why is there confusion about service animals and support animals?
Different federal laws define these animals differently, creating confusion. The ADA, Fair Housing Act, and Air Carrier Access Act have varying categorizations, and terms like ' service animal,' ' emotional support animal,' and ' therapy animal' are often misused interchangeably by the public and media.
Accredited Member of the TheraPetic® Healthcare Provider Group

29 thoughts on “Do Service Dogs Make a Difference?”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *